Flatback vs Butterfly-Back Earrings: Which Should You Choose?

Back to Journal

Choosing between flatback earrings and butterfly-back earrings comes down to how you wear your jewelry. Butterfly backs are designed for earrings you change regularly, while flatbacks are made for pieces you never want to take off.

Neither is objectively better — but they behave very differently on the ear. This guide covers what sets them apart, which suits each piercing and earlobe, and what to consider before you choose.

Flatback vs. Butterfly-Back Earrings at a Glance

FEATURE Flatback Earrings Butterfly-Back Earrings
BEST FOR Everyday pieces you keep in Earrings you change regularly
SLEEPING Most comfortable Can be uncomfortable
SECURITY Threaded or push-fit lock (very secure) Friction fit (can loosen over time)
PUTTING ON Slight learning curve Very easy
CARTILAGE & EAR STACKS Excellent Less ideal

What Are Butterfly-Back Earrings?

Butterfly-back earrings use a straight post secured by a small metal clutch behind the ear. Also called push backs or friction backs, they're the most common type of earring backing and are widely used on everyday stud earrings.

The backing slides onto the post and grips it by friction, which is what makes them so effortless: on in a second, off in a second. That convenience is the whole point — they're built for rotation, for matching earrings to outfits and occasions.

Worth considering: friction is also their limit. The clutch loosens gradually with repeated wear, so it pays to check the grip now and then and gently tighten the "wings." And because the clutch protrudes behind the lobe, most people prefer to take butterfly backs out before sleeping.

What Are Flatback Earrings?

Flatback earrings replace the traditional butterfly clutch with a smooth, flat disc that sits flush against the back of the ear. Sometimes called flat back studs or labret studs, most use either a threadless (push-fit) or internally threaded (screw-in) post, which is why they're a favourite for lobe piercings, cartilage piercings and curated ear stacks.

That locked, low-profile design is why flatbacks are built for staying in: through work, workouts, showers and sleep. Mondays Made flatbacks are also designed to be easy to handle — the post goes in from the front like a regular stud, and the flat disc screws on behind. 

Worth considering: Because the post is a fixed length, fit matters more than it does with a butterfly back (more on that below).

Flatback vs. Butterfly-Back: The Differences That Matter

Beyond the backing itself, four practical differences decide which belongs in each of your piercings.


Which is more comfortable for sleeping and stacking?

Flatback earrings are the more comfortable choice for sleeping and for stacked piercings. A butterfly back sits behind the ear as a small metal clutch. While perfectly comfortable during the day, it can press into the skin when you lie on your side or when multiple earrings are stacked close together. A flatback's disc sits flush, leaving nothing to press, snag or catch — which is why side-sleepers and ear-stack wearers tend to convert to flatbacks and not look back.


Which is more secure?

Flatbacks hold on tighter. A friction clutch can come loose over months of wear and let go if the earring catches on clothing or hair. A threaded or push-fit flatback locks the two halves together, so it stays put through everyday activity.


Which fits your earlobe better?

A butterfly back self-adjusts — the clutch simply sits wherever your lobe ends, so one earring fits nearly every ear. A flatback post is a fixed length, so the fit is part of the choice: too short pinches, while too long lets the earring slip forward in your piercing. 

Mondays Made flatbacks use a 6mm post — the most popular all-round length, made to sit comfortably on most earlobes with just enough breathing room. On thicker lobes the fit is closer and more snug.


Which piercings suit each backing?

Butterfly backs belong on the earrings you rotate — studs, statement pairs and dangles you wear for a day at a time.

Flatbacks work anywhere you want an earring to stay: plenty of wearers make one their signature first-lobe stud, and they truly shine where space is tight — second and third lobe piercings, healed cartilage placements like the helix, forward helix, tragus, conch and flat, and any curated ear stack where a clutch would crowd its neighbours.

Flatbacks to Start With

Which Piercings Are Flatback Earrings Best For?

Flatback earrings are suitable for both lobe and cartilage piercings, including:

  • First, second and third lobe piercings
  • Helix piercings
  • Tragus piercings
  • Conch piercings
  • Forward helix piercings
  • Flat piercings

Their low-profile backing makes them particularly useful in cartilage piercings and curated ear stacks, where multiple earrings sit close together.

So, Which Should You Choose?

The right choice depends less on the jewelry itself and more on how you like to wear it.

Choose butterfly-back earrings if you:

  • Change your earrings regularly
  • Like matching jewelry to different outfits
  • Prefer the quickest backing to put on and take off

Choose flatback earrings if you:

  • Wear the same earrings every day and sleep in them
  • Want a backing that locks rather than grips
  • Have healed cartilage piercings or a curated ear stack

For many people, the answer isn't choosing one over the other. Butterfly backs are perfect for the earrings you rotate, while flatbacks are ideal for the pieces you reach for every day.

Explore our Flatback Earrings →

Are flatback earrings better than butterfly-back earrings?

Neither is objectively better — they're designed for different ways of wearing jewelry. Butterfly backs are ideal for earrings you change regularly, while flatbacks are better suited to jewelry you wear continuously. Most earring wardrobes genuinely benefit from both.

Are flatback earrings hard to put in?

Flatback earrings can take a little practice at first, especially if you're new to threadless or internally threaded jewelry. Mondays Made flatbacks are designed to make this easier: the post goes in from the front like a regular stud, and the flat disc screws on behind. After a few wears, the process takes seconds.

Do flatback earrings stay in better than butterfly backs?

Generally, yes. A butterfly clutch grips by friction alone and loosens with repeated wear, while a flatback's threaded or push-fit post locks the earring together — making it far less likely to fall out if it catches on clothing or hair.

Can you sleep in flatback earrings?

Yes. Their smooth, low-profile backing sits flush against the ear, making them more comfortable to sleep in than traditional butterfly-back earrings.

Do flatback earrings fit thicker earlobes?

Flatback posts come in fixed lengths, so fit depends on the post. Mondays Made flatbacks use a 6mm post — a versatile length that sits comfortably on most earlobes. On thicker lobes, expect a closer, snug fit that keeps the earring from shifting through the day and night.

What are flatback earrings made of?

Quality flatback earrings are made from solid, skin-friendly metals. Mondays Made flatbacks are crafted from a sterling silver (S925) base with 18k gold, rose gold or rhodium vermeil plating, set with D-color, VVS1 moissanites — and are nickel- and lead-free for sensitive ears.

Can you wear flatback earrings in cartilage piercings?

Yes — flatback earrings are a popular choice for healed cartilage piercings such as the helix, tragus and conch, because the flat disc sits comfortably where a butterfly clutch would press or catch. For a piercing that's still healing, follow your piercer's jewelry advice first.

Continue Reading

1 4